Impretzively Fudged is another new Ben & Jerry’s flavor destined to not last for long. The creativity of their ice cream stuff seems to have long gone down the hill and they are now just simply mixing ingredients from their other flavors, not tasting them but hoping one will catch on by magic.
This flavor consists of chocolate ice cream with fudge-crusted pretzel pieces and a pretzel swirl. Basically, it’s a salty and crunchy chocolate ice cream. The chocolate flavor is too strong to let any of the mild pretzel flavor come through, but the pretzels and the pretzel swirl do contribute a light saltiness. I wasn’t a fan of it because I’m just not a fan of chocolate ice cream – but as a fan of salted caramel, I appreciated the salty flavor here as well. And I do like crunch in my ice cream, so that was a plus. Still, I do find chocolate ice cream boring and I won’t finish up the tub (not a bad thing)
These marshmallow flavor ice creams are too sweet and lack flavor.
Ben & Jerry’s introduced two new limited edition marshmallow ice creams and we should all be thankful they’re limited edition. While I bought them on sale at Safeway (regular price is now $7, or 40% more than the $5 they were before the pandemic), I disliked them so much that I feel ripped off – enough that I won’t buy another limited edition flavor without first reading reviews.
Marshmallow Sky consists of marshmallow ice cream with marshmallow swirls and gobs of chocolate chip cookie dough and chocolate chocolate chip cookie dough.
The ice cream itself has no discernible flavor. It was sweet and that’s all I can say about it. It didn’t even taste like sweet cream – just sweetness. The marshmallow swirls were very thin and just added extra sweetness – sweetness upon sweetness and no flavor. The cookie dough globs tasted like what you would expect them to. I’m not a huge fan of cookie dough, but here they were welcomed as they broke through the otherwise tasteless ice cream.
This bright blue ice cream seems to be geared towards children, and I can see them liking it. Adults should give it a pass.
PB S’more is a toasted marshmallow ice cream with peanut butter cups, graham cracker pieces and a marshmallow swirl. It suffered from the same basic problem as Marshmallow Sky, the base ice cream was sweet but otherwise mostly flavorless. The burn marshmallow flavor did give it the occasional caramel note which I did enjoy – as it broke with the monotony of plain sweetness -, so it made it slightly better than the other one, but not much. The marshmallow swirls were thicker, but all they managed to do was added extra sweetness. I like marshmallow fluff, but I think it’s better used on an ice cream with more bitter notes – chocolate, for example. The same can be said about the graham cracker swirl – the tiny crumbs can’t be call pieces. Still, they did add a new flavor. The peanut butter cups were good, as they always are, but discordant with the rest of the vibe of the ice cream. Peanut butter smores might be good – I’ll have to try them – but this ice cream did not make you think of smores at all. It made you think of putting it back in the freezer and drinking something to wash the sweetness away.
Yesterday I made some strawberry ice cream from the Ben and Jerry’s ice cream book, and it was amazingly delicious. I’m not really a fan of strawberry ice cream, but this one was out of this world. I’m sure part of the reason was that I used fresh strawberries bought that same day at the farmers’ market. Definitely use fresh strawberries if you can. Strawberry Ice Cream
1 pint fresh strawberries, hulled & sliced
1/3 cup sugar
juice of 1/2 lemon
2 large eggs
3/4 cup sugar
2 cups whipping cream
1 cup milk Instructions
In a small bowl, mix the strawberries with the sugar and lemon juice. Cover and refrigerate for one hour.
Mash the strawberries to a puree and set aside.
In a medium-size bowl whisk the eggs until light and fluffy. Whisk in the sugar, a little at the time, until fully blended. Add the cream and milk and whisk to blend.
Stir the strawberries into the cream.
Transfer the mixture to an ice cream maker and freeze according to manufacturer’s instructions.
Enjoy!
I think it’s been many years now since Ben & Jerry’s has come out with a flavor of ice cream I actually like. Meanwhile, they’ve gotten rid of many of my favorites, including the best flavor they ever had, Wavy Gravy. Still, I always try the new flavors they come up with, showing that I’m a pretty slow learner.
The latest flavor I tried was ONE Cheesecake Brownie, and seldom have I tasted a more flavorless flavor. The ice cream itself just tasted sour – no cheesiness, no complexity, just a note of sourness. The miniscule cheesecake brownie bits were also sour, though at least a bit chocolaty. They didn’t add much. In all, a complete failure of a flavor.
This ice cream seems to be part of a campaign to “end poverty”, the carton doesn’t explain how, just directs you to a website. I personally find it deeply offensive when big corporate giants like Unilever (Ben & Jerry’s parent company), who themselves contribute to world poverty, by, for example, exploiting child workers, use the plight of poor people as a marketing scheme.
Ben & Jerry’s selling strategy must be based in introducing new flavors, as they do so quite regularly lately. We, of course, have to try them, though it’s been years since we found a new flavor we really liked. For the most part I stick to my old favorite Chubby Hubby and mourn the demise of Wavy Gravy.
So far, I’ve tried 2 of the many new flavors.
I really liked Fossil Fuel, a “Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chocolate Cookie Pieces, Fudge Dinosaurs and a Fudge Swirl”. It reminded me a little of the dearly departed Wavy Gravy, in that it was a light-flavored ice cream with a fudge swirl, alas it doesn’t have the nuts. B&J’s fudge is delicious, though, so I’m glad there is another ice cream that features it.
I wasn’t as excited about The Gobfather, a “Chocolate Ice Cream with Fudge Covered Almonds & a Nougat Swirl”. I’m not a huge chocolate ice cream fan to begin with, and I didn’t feel the almonds or nougat swirl contributed much to it. Indeed, the chocolate flavor is so strong that the nougat was completely drowned.
I also recently had chocolate peanut butter chocolate chip cookie dough – a flavor I can’t find in their website – which I also wasn’t crazy about for similar reasons: the chocolate flavor overwhelmed the cookie dough flavor. I guess no more chocolate-based ice creams for me.
Recent Comments